Jump to content
Dharmaling Forums
Dinara

Сolor Of Shapes

Recommended Posts

Someons asks (Ka cig na re)

If something round it has a color

 

The color of the red apple (cho can)

 

Apple round (phir) it blue? (thel)

 

No reason (ma grub na)

The color of red apple is suitable as a red (common sense) (mdog tu bstan du mar po)

 

No reason (ma grub na)

Edited by Dinara

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dinara, it’s not correct dispute. You can say for example:

 

Someone says (kha cig na re). A : If something is round it has a color

B: Transparent round crystal (chos can). It has a color because it is round(yin par thal). You have to accept pervasion(khyab pa khas).

A: The reason is not established (ma grub)

B: Transparent round crystal (chos can). It is round(yin par thal). Because transparent round crystal is one with itself(yin pai phyir).

 

Then the debate should go as follows:

B: If you agree with the root statement(rtsa bar ‘dod na)…  you can train and write what is next J

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Understand :blink:

 So properly?

 

Someone says (kha cig na re).

 A : If something is round it is red.

B: Color of  white egg  (chos can). It is red because it is round (yin par thal). You have to accept pervasion (khyab pa khas)?

A: The reason is not established (ma grub)  Аrgument of not justified??

B: Color of  white egg  (chos can) is white  because it is is one with Color of  White egg  (Ldog pa)

A: The reason is not established (ma grub)

B: Color of  egg  (chos can) is white  because it is is  covered by white color (khyab pa)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A : If something is round it is red.


B: Color of  white egg  (chos can). It is red because it is round (yin par thal). You have to accept pervasion (khyab pa khas)?


A: The reason is not established (ma grub)  - it means you have to prove that "Color of  white egg is round"


 


...


 


B: Color of  white egg  (chos can) is white  because it is is one with Color of  White egg  


A: The reason is not established (ma grub) -  it means you have to prove that "Color of  white egg is one with Color of  White egg"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

×